Welcome!

Linux Containers Authors: Liz McMillan, Elizabeth White, Zakia Bouachraoui, Pat Romanski, Stefana Muller

Related Topics: Linux Containers

Linux Containers: Article

SCO's IP Gamble

Looking at the challenges from a legal point of view

Anyone reading this is likely aware of The SCO Group's claim to intellectual property (IP) rights in the Linux kernel. SCO hired legal guru David Boies (who prosecuted the government's case against Microsoft) and initiated a two-pronged litigation and marketing attack.

To recap: in March 2003 SCO sued IBM for breach of its software agreements with SCO, misappropriation of SCO's trade secrets in Unix, and wrongful dissemination of those trade secrets via IBM's contributions to open source and Linux. In May, SCO wrote to 1,500 of the world's largest companies, asserting that Linux infringes SCO's IP rights and that end users may face legal liability from the use of Linux. In July, SCO registered for copyrights in its Unix-based systems, and in August announced the availability of a $699 per CPU system "license" for Linux end users "to cure the SCO IP infringement issues for Linux operating systems." And SCO has engaged in an aggressive press campaign, repeatedly asserting that Linux software developers violated SCO's Unix IP rights.

It's no secret that SCO is banking heavily on its IP strategy to achieve profitability after years of multiple million-dollar losses. SCO acknowledged that licensing income would be used in part to "continue our intellectual property protection and licensing initiative," i.e., funding its legal battles with IBM and others such as Red Hat, who initiated a lawsuit against SCO in August in an effort to clear the SCO-created cloud from Red Hat Linux. The plan has worked so far, as SCO's Q3-FY2003 results show positive net income (due primarily to $7.3 million in licensing revenue) and its stock price has risen eightfold since March.

While the open source community fumes, SCO's IP strategy is far from new. As an industry matures, it becomes a target for IP holders. The semiconductor industry saw an explosion of patent litigation in the 1980s, as companies jockeyed for market share and used their IP to protect that share and generate revenue. Texas Instruments, for example, reported patent licensing revenue of $521 million in 1993, primarily from its semiconductorrelated patents; this was more income than TI made from selling semiconductor products. IBM itself is no stranger to the IP game, reportedly realizing $1.7 billion in patent royalties in 2001. And well-known organizations such as the Lemelson Foundation and Ronald A. Katz Technology Licensing do not make or sell products at all, but generate billions of dollars in revenue from patent litigation and licensing.

SCO's effort to emulate these companies, however, is a long shot at best. SCO's asserted IP rights are limited to copyright and trade secrets, whereas successful licensors historically rely on patent rights. The differences are significant. One key distinction is that patent infringement is a strictliability claim; a company so charged cannot rely on the fact that it independently designed the infringing technology. In contrast, copyright and trade secret claims are both subject to the defense of independent creation. Another difference is that welldrafted patents may provide very broad protection over a particular invention, for example, by covering all methods of producing a product or achieving a specific result. Source code copyright claims, however, require more than showing that the offending code achieves the same result as the copyrighted code – there must be evidence that the offending code was copied, at least in part, from the copyrighted code.

These differences mean that IBM and Red Hat may defeat SCO's copyright and trade secret claims by showing they independently wrote the Linux code in question. Further, trade secret claims may also be defeated by showing the "secret" was not properly maintained or was subject to discovery through reverseengineering. This latter point is particularly relevant, as SCO openly marketed UnitedLinux 1.0, and therefore arguably disclosed the very trade secrets (presumably, Unix functionality – SCO has been vague on this point) it now seeks to protect.

SCO faces other challenges. In a countersuit, IBM claimed that SCO's distribution of UnitedLinux was subject to the terms of the General Public License (GPL), and that SCO's attempt to collect licensing fees violates those terms. IBM also sued SCO for patent infringement, asserting four patents against a broad array of SCO products.

Without its own patent claims, the deck is stacked against SCO, and if IBM and/or Red Hat succeeds on the merits, SCO's IP claims against others will be toothless. Nonetheless, there are very few certainties in litigation, as IBM and Red Hat well know. If SCO mounts enough of an attack to sustain the cases towards trial, the risks may be too great for IBM and Red Hat to continue, and settlement is possible. If that occurs, the rest of the industry best be prepared to open its checkbook. And while SCO may be the first to attack the open source community, history shows others will follow. As the popularity of Linux grows, the suppliers of Linux operating systems (i.e., those that generate revenue from Linux product sales) inevitably become a more inviting target for IP holders worldwide.

More Stories By Brian Ferguson

Brian E. Ferguson is a partner in the Washington, D.C. office of the international law firm McDermott, Will & Emery. He specializes in intellectual property litigation and counseling.

Comments (4)

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


IoT & Smart Cities Stories
At CloudEXPO Silicon Valley, June 24-26, 2019, Digital Transformation (DX) is a major focus with expanded DevOpsSUMMIT and FinTechEXPO programs within the DXWorldEXPO agenda. Successful transformation requires a laser focus on being data-driven and on using all the tools available that enable transformation if they plan to survive over the long term. A total of 88% of Fortune 500 companies from a generation ago are now out of business. Only 12% still survive. Similar percentages are found throug...
Druva is the global leader in Cloud Data Protection and Management, delivering the industry's first data management-as-a-service solution that aggregates data from endpoints, servers and cloud applications and leverages the public cloud to offer a single pane of glass to enable data protection, governance and intelligence-dramatically increasing the availability and visibility of business critical information, while reducing the risk, cost and complexity of managing and protecting it. Druva's...
BMC has unmatched experience in IT management, supporting 92 of the Forbes Global 100, and earning recognition as an ITSM Gartner Magic Quadrant Leader for five years running. Our solutions offer speed, agility, and efficiency to tackle business challenges in the areas of service management, automation, operations, and the mainframe.
The Jevons Paradox suggests that when technological advances increase efficiency of a resource, it results in an overall increase in consumption. Writing on the increased use of coal as a result of technological improvements, 19th-century economist William Stanley Jevons found that these improvements led to the development of new ways to utilize coal. In his session at 19th Cloud Expo, Mark Thiele, Chief Strategy Officer for Apcera, compared the Jevons Paradox to modern-day enterprise IT, examin...
With 10 simultaneous tracks, keynotes, general sessions and targeted breakout classes, @CloudEXPO and DXWorldEXPO are two of the most important technology events of the year. Since its launch over eight years ago, @CloudEXPO and DXWorldEXPO have presented a rock star faculty as well as showcased hundreds of sponsors and exhibitors! In this blog post, we provide 7 tips on how, as part of our world-class faculty, you can deliver one of the most popular sessions at our events. But before reading...
DSR is a supplier of project management, consultancy services and IT solutions that increase effectiveness of a company's operations in the production sector. The company combines in-depth knowledge of international companies with expert knowledge utilising IT tools that support manufacturing and distribution processes. DSR ensures optimization and integration of internal processes which is necessary for companies to grow rapidly. The rapid growth is possible thanks, to specialized services an...
At CloudEXPO Silicon Valley, June 24-26, 2019, Digital Transformation (DX) is a major focus with expanded DevOpsSUMMIT and FinTechEXPO programs within the DXWorldEXPO agenda. Successful transformation requires a laser focus on being data-driven and on using all the tools available that enable transformation if they plan to survive over the long term. A total of 88% of Fortune 500 companies from a generation ago are now out of business. Only 12% still survive. Similar percentages are found throug...
There are many examples of disruption in consumer space – Uber disrupting the cab industry, Airbnb disrupting the hospitality industry and so on; but have you wondered who is disrupting support and operations? AISERA helps make businesses and customers successful by offering consumer-like user experience for support and operations. We have built the world’s first AI-driven IT / HR / Cloud / Customer Support and Operations solution.
Codete accelerates their clients growth through technological expertise and experience. Codite team works with organizations to meet the challenges that digitalization presents. Their clients include digital start-ups as well as established enterprises in the IT industry. To stay competitive in a highly innovative IT industry, strong R&D departments and bold spin-off initiatives is a must. Codete Data Science and Software Architects teams help corporate clients to stay up to date with the mod...
Scala Hosting is trusted by 50 000 customers from 120 countries and hosting 700 000+ websites. The company has local presence in the United States and Europe and runs an internal R&D department which focuses on changing the status quo in the web hosting industry. Imagine every website owner running their online business on a fully managed cloud VPS platform at an affordable price that's very close to the price of shared hosting. The efforts of the R&D department in the last 3 years made that pos...