Welcome!

Linux Containers Authors: Elizabeth White, Yeshim Deniz, Liz McMillan, Sematext Blog, Derek Weeks

Related Topics: Linux Containers

Linux Containers: Article

Principles of Secure Programming

Applying basic security principles to programming

The purpose of this article is to show how basic security principles can help you develop programs that are harder for the bad guys to break. We'll examine a simple function that executes a command as though it were typed at the keyboard, exactly what the library function system does. But unlike many system implementations, we'll constrain what happens so the calling program can't trick it into executing some other program.

The system function takes a single argument: a character string with the command to be executed just as it would be typed at the keyboard. The function first invokes the Bourne shell, passing the command to that shell using the "–c" option. The shell then spawns the command. For example:

system("date")
invokes the command
/bin/sh –c "date"

This executes the program "date," which prints the date on the standard output.

Security Issues
Security issues arise when the program invoking the system function is a privileged program. The "privilege" may consist of having setuid and/or setgid privileges such as su or being able to run one of a specified set of programs such as a Web server serving CGI scripts. The attacker's goal is to trick the program into executing some other program, for example a version of date that's a command interpreter rather than just printing the date.

Problems arise because of the power of the Bourne shell as a command interpreter. That shell takes information from the environment, which consists of shell variables, file descriptors, signal-handling routines, and any other aspects of the process space that could affect program execution. For our purposes, we'll just consider environment variables.

One relevant environment variable is the PATH environment variable. When given a command that doesn't contain a '/' the Bourne shell treats the value of the PATH variable as a sequence of directory names. It looks in each directory in the given order for a program named "date" and executes the first one found. Suppose an attacker finds a setuid-to-root program that uses system to run the "date" command. The attacker can then copy the shell into a file named "date" in her current working directory, prepend "." to the list of directories in the value of PATH, and then execute the program. When system invokes the shell, it searches each directory in the value of PATH in order for a command named "date." The first directory searched will be the current working directory. The shell will find a program called "date" there and execute it, spawning the command interpreter, which will run with root privileges.

Our goal is to construct a version of system that's invulnerable to this kind of attack. Specifically, we want to guarantee that when the caller passes a command name to system, the user can't cause the program to execute a different program.

Applying the Principles
We'll apply two principles of secure design and implementation. They come from a paper by Jerome Saltzer and Michael Schroeder and are central to any security work. In practice, we would also consider the other six, but the two we'll use have more impact on the design and implementation of this particular function than the others.

Principle of Least Privilege
The first principle is the principle of least privilege. This principle, also called the need-to-know principle, says that a process should have the minimum privileges needed to perform its task. For this problem, this rule says that system should execute the command with the privileges of the user, not with those of root, if at all possible. As an example, were the privileged program to print the date and time by using system to run the command "date" as described above, there's no reason that "date" needs to be executed as root. It could just as easily be executed with the user's privileges. Hence the first step in our new system command would be to let the caller reset the privileges to those of the real user and group. Doing this means that the user can only compromise her own account - and as since she already has full access to it such a compromise is meaningless.

If the caller lets the user select one of a set of commands, then a different application of the principle of least privilege provides the required restriction. The program configuration should create a directory into which copies of the commands to be executed are placed. Then the program changes its notion of the root directory to that of the directory containing the commands. Even if the user can enter the name of a different command, only the authorized commands are accessible to the program. So only the authorized commands can be executed, and the user will get an error message. This is the technique that sendmail's restricted shell uses to ensure that sendmail only executes safe programs like procmail and vacation. Web servers should use this technique to ensure that commands to execute CGI programs can only execute the CGI programs in the Web server's directories.

Principle of Fail-Safe Defaults
The principle of fail-safe defaults says that access to resources and objects should be denied by default. If you need access to only one particular object, the usual approach of removing access to all other objects violates this principle. Instead, access to all objects should be removed, and then access privileges for that particular object should be explicitly granted. The distinction is subtle, but critical.

To see this, consider the problem of ensuring the user's PATH environment variable is set appropriately. The naive approach is to search the environment for the PATH environment variable and check that its value is acceptable. This leads to two problems. First, what happens if the value is not acceptable? In this case, the value must be replaced. Second, what happens if there are multiple occurrences of the variable? The values of all must be checked and found satisfactory, or all but one must be deleted.

A second approach is to require that the program use the full path name of the program. So the invocation of the system call would be:

system("/bin/date")

This causes the shell to ignore the PATH setting. Unfortunately, this approach is also flawed.

Environment variables other than PATH affect the executed program. For some versions of the Bourne shell, the value of the environment variable IFS is a string of characters that the shell treats as word separators. (This is particularly useful when a shell script is reading lines from the password file, for example.) In such a shell, the following command prints files X and Y:

IFS="/$IFS"; export IFS; cat/x/y

because the shell sees the "/" character as a word separator, which lets the user thwart the use of a full path name as described above. All she need do is set IFS in her environment to include the "/" character and then create a program called "bin" in her current working directory. She then changes her PATH environment variable to look in the current working directory first. When she runs the command, the privileged program invokes the above system function. The subordinate shell reads the argument of system as having two words, "bin" followed by the argument "date." Hence the user's program "bin" will be executed and the shell will pass "date" to it as an argument.

Again the programmer can try to prevent this by setting IFS explicitly in the environment:

system("IFS=\" \t\n\"; export IFS; /bin/date")

As tempting as this approach is, it suffers from two problems. The first is that the attacker can easily defeat it by adding "I" to the IFS variable. Then the shell sees this as adding the environment variable FS to the environment. The second problem arises when the attacker doesn't do this. There are now two occurrences of the IFS environment variable in the environment. Which one is used? That turns out to be implementation-dependent: some versions of the shell use the first (the user's), and others use the second (the one defined in the system argument.

Following the principle of fail-safe defaults offers a simple answer to all this. First, create an empty environment for the shell. Then add preset, safe values of PATH, IFS, and any other needed environment variables to that environment. Finally, set the shell's environment to be the newly created one. Doing so makes the user's environment irrelevant to the system function and the shell it calls. The shell never refers to the user's environment. The shell only uses the newly created safe environment.

Now the order in which the shell evaluates the variables in the environment is irrelevant, because there is only one occurrence of each variable in the environment. If the user adds "/" to the value of IFS in her environment, or alters the value of the PATH environment variable, the shell ignores those changes because it never sees the values of those variables. It only sees the ones defined in the environment set up by the program.

Conclusion
Programming with security in mind is critical for today's programs. This style of programming requires a methodical approach, not one in which various tricks are used without understanding how and why they work. The problem is that tricks only apply to certain situations, and can only be used effectively if those situations arise. But the principles of secure design and implementation apply always, and dramatically improve both the quality and the security of the programs and systems they are applied to.

Recommended Reading

  • J. Saltzer and M. Schroeder, "The Protection of Information in Computer Systems," Proceedings of the IEEE 63 (9) pp. 1278-1308 (September 1975). This paper first enunciated the principles and discussed them thoroughly in a variety of contexts. A must read for anyone doing design and/or implementation in the field of computer security.
  • B. Kernighan and P. Plauger, The Elements of Programming Style, McGraw-Hill Book Co., Reading, MA (1974). The principles described in this book lead to a clear and readable programming style. Their emphasis on simplicity and clarity parallels principles in security. Highly recommended.
  • M. Graff and K. Van Wyk, Secure Coding: Principles and Practices, O'Reilly and Associates, Sebastopol, CA (June 2003). This book describes security through the lifecycle of a program or system. An excellent high-level view of how to write code that emphasizes security.
  • J. Viega and G. McGraw, Building Secure Software: How to Avoid Security Problems the Right Way, Addison-Wesley Publishing Co., Boston, MA (2002). This book discusses both principles and practice, drawing most of its examples from Unix and Linux systems. Another must read for Unix and Linux programmers.
  • M. Howard and D. LeBlanc, Writing Secure Code, Microsoft Press, Redmond, WA (2001). Similar to Viega and McGraw but focusing on Windows platforms, this book shows the application of principles to a different environment. A must read for Windows developers, and a worthwhile read for Unix and Linux programmers interested in a different programming environment.
  • A. Stavely, Towards Zero-Defect Programming, Addison-Wesley Publishing Co., Reading, MA (1998). Although focused on correctness more than security, its ideas can be readily adapted to security. Its mix of formalism and informality is refreshing.
  • More Stories By Matt Bishop

    Matt Bishop is a professor in the Department of Computer Science at the University of California at Davis. A recognized expert in vulnerability analysis, secure systems/software design, network security, access control, authentication, and UNIX security, Bishop also works to improve computer security instruction. He is the author of Computer Security: Art and Science and Introduction to Computer Security (Addison-Wesley).

    Comments (0)

    Share your thoughts on this story.

    Add your comment
    You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

    In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


    @ThingsExpo Stories
    The Internet of Things is clearly many things: data collection and analytics, wearables, Smart Grids and Smart Cities, the Industrial Internet, and more. Cool platforms like Arduino, Raspberry Pi, Intel's Galileo and Edison, and a diverse world of sensors are making the IoT a great toy box for developers in all these areas. In this Power Panel at @ThingsExpo, moderated by Conference Chair Roger Strukhoff, panelists discussed what things are the most important, which will have the most profound e...
    Keeping pace with advancements in software delivery processes and tooling is taxing even for the most proficient organizations. Point tools, platforms, open source and the increasing adoption of private and public cloud services requires strong engineering rigor - all in the face of developer demands to use the tools of choice. As Agile has settled in as a mainstream practice, now DevOps has emerged as the next wave to improve software delivery speed and output. To make DevOps work, organization...
    My team embarked on building a data lake for our sales and marketing data to better understand customer journeys. This required building a hybrid data pipeline to connect our cloud CRM with the new Hadoop Data Lake. One challenge is that IT was not in a position to provide support until we proved value and marketing did not have the experience, so we embarked on the journey ourselves within the product marketing team for our line of business within Progress. In his session at @BigDataExpo, Sum...
    Web Real-Time Communication APIs have quickly revolutionized what browsers are capable of. In addition to video and audio streams, we can now bi-directionally send arbitrary data over WebRTC's PeerConnection Data Channels. With the advent of Progressive Web Apps and new hardware APIs such as WebBluetooh and WebUSB, we can finally enable users to stitch together the Internet of Things directly from their browsers while communicating privately and securely in a decentralized way.
    DevOps is often described as a combination of technology and culture. Without both, DevOps isn't complete. However, applying the culture to outdated technology is a recipe for disaster; as response times grow and connections between teams are delayed by technology, the culture will die. A Nutanix Enterprise Cloud has many benefits that provide the needed base for a true DevOps paradigm.
    What sort of WebRTC based applications can we expect to see over the next year and beyond? One way to predict development trends is to see what sorts of applications startups are building. In his session at @ThingsExpo, Arin Sime, founder of WebRTC.ventures, will discuss the current and likely future trends in WebRTC application development based on real requests for custom applications from real customers, as well as other public sources of information,
    In his General Session at 17th Cloud Expo, Bruce Swann, Senior Product Marketing Manager for Adobe Campaign, explored the key ingredients of cross-channel marketing in a digital world. Learn how the Adobe Marketing Cloud can help marketers embrace opportunities for personalized, relevant and real-time customer engagement across offline (direct mail, point of sale, call center) and digital (email, website, SMS, mobile apps, social networks, connected objects).
    With the introduction of IoT and Smart Living in every aspect of our lives, one question has become relevant: What are the security implications? To answer this, first we have to look and explore the security models of the technologies that IoT is founded upon. In his session at @ThingsExpo, Nevi Kaja, a Research Engineer at Ford Motor Company, will discuss some of the security challenges of the IoT infrastructure and relate how these aspects impact Smart Living. The material will be delivered i...
    "My role is working with customers, helping them go through this digital transformation. I spend a lot of time talking to banks, big industries, manufacturers working through how they are integrating and transforming their IT platforms and moving them forward," explained William Morrish, General Manager Product Sales at Interoute, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 18th Cloud Expo, held June 7-9, 2016, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY.
    SYS-CON Events announced today that Ocean9will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Ocean9 provides cloud services for Backup, Disaster Recovery (DRaaS) and instant Innovation, and redefines enterprise infrastructure with its cloud native subscription offerings for mission critical SAP workloads.
    Your homes and cars can be automated and self-serviced. Why can't your storage? From simply asking questions to analyze and troubleshoot your infrastructure, to provisioning storage with snapshots, recovery and replication, your wildest sci-fi dream has come true. In his session at @DevOpsSummit at 20th Cloud Expo, Dan Florea, Director of Product Management at Tintri, will provide a ChatOps demo where you can talk to your storage and manage it from anywhere, through Slack and similar services ...
    In his session at @ThingsExpo, Eric Lachapelle, CEO of the Professional Evaluation and Certification Board (PECB), will provide an overview of various initiatives to certifiy the security of connected devices and future trends in ensuring public trust of IoT. Eric Lachapelle is the Chief Executive Officer of the Professional Evaluation and Certification Board (PECB), an international certification body. His role is to help companies and individuals to achieve professional, accredited and worldw...
    SYS-CON Events announced today that Linux Academy, the foremost online Linux and cloud training platform and community, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Linux Academy was founded on the belief that providing high-quality, in-depth training should be available at an affordable price. Industry leaders in quality training, provided services, and student certification passes, its goal is to c...
    "delaPlex is a software development company. We do team-based outsourcing development," explained Mark Rivers, COO and Co-founder of delaPlex Software, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 18th Cloud Expo, held June 7-9, 2016, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY.
    SYS-CON Events announced today that SoftLayer, an IBM Company, has been named “Gold Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 18th Cloud Expo, which will take place on June 7-9, 2016, at the Javits Center in New York, New York. SoftLayer, an IBM Company, provides cloud infrastructure as a service from a growing number of data centers and network points of presence around the world. SoftLayer’s customers range from Web startups to global enterprises.
    SYS-CON Events announced today that Technologic Systems Inc., an embedded systems solutions company, will exhibit at SYS-CON's @ThingsExpo, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Technologic Systems is an embedded systems company with headquarters in Fountain Hills, Arizona. They have been in business for 32 years, helping more than 8,000 OEM customers and building over a hundred COTS products that have never been discontinued. Technologic Systems’ pr...
    SYS-CON Events announced today that CA Technologies has been named “Platinum Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY, and the 21st International Cloud Expo®, which will take place October 31-November 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. CA Technologies helps customers succeed in a future where every business – from apparel to energy – is being rewritten by software. From ...
    In his keynote at @ThingsExpo, Chris Matthieu, Director of IoT Engineering at Citrix and co-founder and CTO of Octoblu, focused on building an IoT platform and company. He provided a behind-the-scenes look at Octoblu’s platform, business, and pivots along the way (including the Citrix acquisition of Octoblu).
    SYS-CON Events announced today that Loom Systems will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Founded in 2015, Loom Systems delivers an advanced AI solution to predict and prevent problems in the digital business. Loom stands alone in the industry as an AI analysis platform requiring no prior math knowledge from operators, leveraging the existing staff to succeed in the digital era. With offices in S...
    SYS-CON Events announced today that HTBase will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. HTBase (Gartner 2016 Cool Vendor) delivers a Composable IT infrastructure solution architected for agility and increased efficiency. It turns compute, storage, and fabric into fluid pools of resources that are easily composed and re-composed to meet each application’s needs. With HTBase, companies can quickly prov...